file:///Users/musiclab-mbp1/Downloads/media_reviews/2002_09_29_sandiegotribune.html 3/5
vilification of research conducted by anthropologist Napoleon
Chagnon and geneticist James Neel among the Yanomamo – in
this case, the accusations involved such alleged behaviors as
fabricating data, causing violence among the Yanomamo and
deliberately infecting the Yanomamo with potentially fatal disease
and withholding medical treatment in order to test genetic theories.
In both cases, accusations ranged far afield, even involving attacks
on the researchers' alleged personal and political motivations. For
both of these controversies, Pinker expresses strong and clear
support for the researchers, and denounces the extreme claims
and tactics that were used against them.
In Part III, "Human Nature With a Human Face," Pinker explores
why so many people find a biological component of human nature
to be a dangerous idea. What are we afraid of? The four chapters
in this section explore four fears: the fear of inequality, of
imperfectibility, of determinism and of nihilism. For example, the
author notes that "fear of the terrible consequences that might arise
from a discovery of innate differences has ... led many intellectuals
to insist that such differences do not exist ..." but he says other
approaches are possible: "The problem is with the line of
reasoning that says that if people do turn out to be different, then
discrimination, oppression, or genocide would be OK after all."
He then demonstrates why he believes that reasoning is flawed.
Part IV, "Know Thyself," investigates human nature still more
deeply: what it seems to be, and how and why it may have
developed that way. Pinker's evolution-based discussions explore
intriguing topics such as kinship, sexuality and love, morality,
conflict and gamesmanship.
He engages the reader in dialogues that heighten interest while
emphasizing the point at hand. For example, consider this stunning
question regarding parenthood, from a chapter entitled "The Many
Roots of Our Suffering:" "Moral philosophers play with a
hypothetical dilemma in which people can run through the left door
of a burning building to save some number of children or through
the right door to save their own child. If you are a parent, ponder
this question: Is there any number of children that would lead you
to pick the left door?"
Part V, "Hot Buttons," examines five controversial topics in light of
what has been previously discussed: politics, violence, gender,
children and the arts. Each is explored in depth in its own chapter,
and Pinker presents detailed and fascinating analyses of these
thorny issues.
In the concluding section, Part VI, "The Voice of the Species,"