6
Directions: Read the story and answer the questions that follow.
Foolish Choice, Wise Lesson
1 Once there was a tailor named Nicholas who was known far and wide for making fine
clothing. Nicholas took great pride in everything he made, which is why his shop was
often busy. Every night Nicholas would retire
to the small cottage behind his shop that he
shared with his daughter, Tanya.
2 Tanya was a bright girl, but she was vain and spoiled. She wasted her days admiring
herself in the mirror and brushing her long, beautiful hair. Her father’s shop was the
busiest in the village, but she would not pick up a needle to help him. When customers
sang the praises of his well-made clothes, she snorted, “They are too plain.”
3 Nicholas loved his daughter, but he hoped to find a way to help her realize that beauty lies
within. He worried that she did not value the things that were important. He became
puzzled over the problem. One day help arrived in the form of the village peddler. Every
Saturday the peddler drove his wagon past the shops and cottages in the village. He sold
all kinds of goods, and people crowded around him to buy everything from kitchen pots to
silk dresses.
4 One Saturday while looking at the peddler’s goods, Nicholas was struck with an idea that
could help Tanya. He purchased two small boxes. One was bright gold and covered with
sparkling stones. The other was made of dark wood with worn edges and corners. At the
end of the day, Nicholas found Tanya in the cottage. He showed her the two boxes. “You
may have only one,” he told her. “Be careful how you choose.”
5 Tanya paid no attention to his warning because she was too drawn to the sparkling box.
“Oh, Papa, there is no need to be careful! The wooden box is old and ugly, and I would
be too embarrassed to own it.” She quickly seized the other box, but she gasped when
she saw the truth. “Papa!” she cried. “I thought this box was covered with diamonds, but
they are just pieces of glass!” Then she raised the lid. “This box is empty! Why would you
want to trick me?”
6 “Tanya,” Nicholas replied, “I care for you very much. I only want to teach you a valuable
lesson. Look at the boxes closely, my dear. You will find that appearances are not always
what they seem to be.”
7 As Tanya closed the box, she saw it as though with new eyes. Looking carefully at the
edges of the box, she could see where the cheap golden paint was beginning to chip.
Tanya picked away a flake of paint from the tin box. Thoughtfully, she glanced from her
soft fingers to the strong, creased hands of her father that looked worn from many years
of hard work. Tanya looked at the box he held in his own hands. It could have been more
than one hundred years old. Its former owner had loved it well. The wood was well oiled
and had a dark, pleasing shine. Despite the small bumps and scratches, it appeared
capable of lasting one hundred years more.