Furthermore, there are no witnesses who could testify credibly that Wilson shot Brown
while Brown was clearly attempting to surrender. The accounts of the witnesses who have
claimed that Brown raised his hands above his head to surrender and said âI donât have a gun,â
or âokay, okay, okayâ are inconsistent with the physical evidence or can be challenged in other
material ways, and thus cannot be relied upon to form the foundation of a federal prosecution.
28
The two most prominent witnesses who have stated that Brown was shot with his hands up in
surrender are Witness 101 and Witness 127, both of whom claim that Brown turned around with
his hands raised in surrender, that he never reached for his waistband, that he never moved
forward toward Wilson after turning to face him with his hands up, and that he fell to the ground
with his hands raised. These and other aspects of their statements are contradicted by the
physical evidence. Crime scene photographs establish that Brown fell to the ground with his left
hand at his waistband and his right hand at his side. Brownâs blood in the roadway demonstrates
that Brown came forward at least 21.6 feet from the time he turned around toward Wilson. Other
aspects of the accounts of Witness 101 and Witness 127 would render them not credible in a
prosecution of Wilson, namely their accounts of what happened at the SUV. Both claim that
Wilson fired the first shot out the SUV window, Witness 101 claims that the shot hit Brown at
close range in the torso, and both claim that Brown did not reach inside the vehicle. These
claims are irreconcilable with the bullet in the SUV door, the close-range wound to Brownâs
hand, Brownâs DNA inside Wilsonâs car and on his gun, and the injuries to Wilsonâs face.
Other witnesses who have suggested that Brown was shot with his hands up in surrender
have either recanted their statements, such as Witnesses 119 and 125, provided inconsistent
statements, such as Witness 124, or have provided accounts that are verifiably untrue, such as
Witnesses 121, 139, and 132. Witness 122 recanted significant portions of his statement by
acknowledging that he was not in a position to see what either Brown or Wilson were doing, and
who falsely insisted that three police officers pursued Brown and that the shooter was heavy set
(in contrast to the slimly-built Wilson). Similar to Witness 128, Witness 122 told Brownâs
family that Brown had been shot execution-style. Witness 120 initially told law enforcement
that he saw Brown shot at point-blank range as he was on his knees with his hands up. Similar to
Witness 138, Witness 120 subsequently acknowledged that he did not see Brown get shot but
âassumedâ he had been executed while on his knees with his hands up based on âcommon senseâ
and what others âin the community told [him.]â There is no witness who has stated that Brown
had his hands up in surrender whose statement is otherwise consistent with the physical
evidence. For example, some witnesses say that Wilson only fired his weapon out of the SUV,
(e.g. Witnesses 128, 101, and 127) or that Wilson stood next to the SUV and killed Brown right
there (e.g. Witnesses 139, 132, 120). Some witnesses insist that Wilson shot Brown in the back
as he lay on the ground. (e.g. Witnesses 128 and 139). Some witnesses say that Wilson shot
Brown and he went to the ground immediately upon turning to face Wilson. (e.g. Witnesses 138,
101, 118, and 127). Some say Wilson went to the ground with his hands raised at right angles.
(e.g. Witnesses 138, 118, and 121). Again, all of these statements are contradicted by the
physical and forensic evidence, which also undermines the credibility of their accounts of other
aspects of the incident, including their assertion that Brown had his hands up in a surrender
position when Wilson shot him.
28
The media has widely reported that there is witness testimony that Brown said âdonât shootâ as
he held his hands above his head. In fact, our investigation did not reveal any eyewitness who
stated that Brown said âdonât shoot.â
83