HAL Id: hal-04354188
https://univ-montpellier3-paul-valery.hal.science/hal-04354188
Submitted on 19 Dec 2023
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entic research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diusion de documents
scientiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Disney’s Star Wars: Forces of Production, Promotion,
and Reception. William Proctor and Richard McCulloch
(eds.). Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 2019, 396 p.
Hervé Mayer
To cite this version:
Hervé Mayer. Disney’s Star Wars: Forces of Production, Promotion, and Reception. William Proctor
and Richard McCulloch (eds.). Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 2019, 396 p.. Caliban : French
journal of English studies, 2020, 63, �10.4000/caliban.8195�. �hal-04354188�
Reviews, Caliban n°63
Disneys Star Wars: Forces of Production, Promotion, and Reception. William
Proctor and Richard McCulloch (eds.). Iowa City: University of Iowa Press,
2019, ISBN 978-1-60938-643-6, 396 p.
Hervé Mayer, Université Paul-Valéry Montpellier 3
This edited collection on Disneys Star Wars is a much-needed assessment of the impact of Disneys
Lucasfilm purchase on production, promotion and reception of the Star Wars franchise across media. The
collection brings together contributors from the film industry and academics specializing in media and visual
studies as well as communication and fan studies. The twenty-one chapters are organized in two parts:
production and promotion, and reception and participation. The book proposes a well-researched overview of
the impact of the buyout in various areas and is noteworthy for its contributions in corporate production
studies and fan studies..
In their introduction, Proctor and McCulloch discuss the purchase of Lucasfilm in 2012 in light of
George Lucass prior relationship to Disney and contradictory declarations about a sequel trilogy, arguing
that Disneys main strategy was “not to rebrand Star Wars by constructing a binary between Lucasfilm and
Disney but, rather, by unifying them in order to instill trust and belief” (11). The editors then announce the
aim of the collection, which is to distinguish “key shifts that have occurred at the level of industry, narrative,
and reception” since the Disney acquisition and “examine the ways in which ownership, conglomeration, and
branding operate within the postmillenial mediascape” (12).
The first part of the volume, “Production and Promotion, opens with three chapters focusing on
brand synergy. Matthew Freemans chapter on “Rebuilding Transmedia Star Wars analyzes the ways in
which Disney shifted the status and content of the Star Wars Expanded Universe to create a discourse of
legitimacy and canon. Disney rebranded the Expanded Universe Star Wars Legends and presented its texts as
alternatives, using imagination as a specific world-building approach connecting Disneys Star Wars
productions to Lucasfilms. Similarly, Matt Hills chapter on “Transmedia Spectacle and Transownership
Storytelling as Seen on TV examines the position of televisual productions within the Star Wars universe,
pre- and post-acquisition. It compares the Holiday Special (1978) to Rebels (2014-2018) and shows that the
latter used aesthetics and narrative as another bridge between past and present owners. The brand synergy is
further exemplified in Lincoln Geraghty’s “Rebuilding the Force, Brick by Brick stressing the role of
LEGO and LEGO-book publisher Dorling Kindersley in the process. Dan Hassler-Forest work on Fan
Labor and Brand Management” discusses how the promotion of The Force Awakens relied on a form of
immaterial fan labor and collaborative, yet asymmetric, brand management. The film’s promotion rested on
nostalgia for the original trilogy, but also incorporated fan participation: “fan culture’s transformative
creative work is itself transformed into something that can be used to rebrand not only the Star Wars
franchise but also the conglomerate of which it is a part” (80). In Rebellions Are Built on Realism,” Joshua
Wucher argues that the use of special effects in the film Rogue One is heir to the Lucasfilm tradition. Both
Rogue One and promotional paratexts reprised the original trilogys analog and digital special effects
traditions in ways that ensured fidelity. Colin B. Harveys “Binding the Galaxy Together” stresses further the
link with tradition and investigates the role of memory in the construction of the Star Wars franchises
transmedia network. He compares memory practices pre- and post-acquisition in relation to the increasingly
connective digital practices of fans engagement with the franchise.
The first part closes with three chapters that study the effects of Disneys purchase at the narrative and
aesthetic level across different media. Ross Garners “The Mandalorian Variation” focuses more specifically
on the limiting impact of Disney’s acquisition on the franchise’s gender identity and dynamics, and more
particularly on the construction of the lead action female character in the TV series Star Wars Rebels.
Douglas Brown analyses the impact of the acquisition on Star Wars videogames in “To Disney Infinity and
Beyond. Comparing classic Star Wars games with three post-acquisition releases, Brown finds that pre-
acquisition games were bolder in experimenting articulations to the franchise. Finally, Rebecca Williamss
“From Star Tours to Galaxy’s Edge” examines the ways in which the history of Lucasfilm and Disney
intertwined before the Disney buyout through the Star Tours immersive rides featured in Disneys theme
parks since the mid-1980s. She argues the rides completed the transmedia world of Star Wars by extending
Reviews, Caliban n°63
fan experiences “from the textual into the bodily and the spatial” (136), making them more immersive and
personal.
Part II of the collection on “Reception and Participation” starts with two chapters addressing the
critical responses to Disney productions and the role played by nostalgia in both promotion and reception.
Jonathan Gray’s chapter responds to the critical appraisal of The Force Awakens as an unimaginative remake
of A New Hope. The author addresses the question of franchises relationship to originality, nostalgia, and
repetition, arguing that The Force Awakenss mode of relation to A New Hope is one of reflexivity. Another
way of redefining nostalgia was to appeal to fans disappointed by the Disney acquisition through subcultural
branding as argued by Emma Pett in “Real Life is Rubbish”, her examination of the promotion and reception
of Secret Cinema’s 2015 immersive production of The Empire Strikes Back (1980).
The next two chapters explore gendered politics in Disney Star Wars. Paul Booths “Disney’s Princess
Leia” focuses on controversy regarding the character and Disney’s handling of the conversation. One way to
avoid criticisms of gender normativity was to shift toy manufacturer for the Princess toys from Mattel to
Hasbroa company mostly making toys for boys. Another was to promote Leia to the role of general in The
Force Awakens. But Disney also emphasized the more princess-like attributes of Princess Leia in the Disney-
Marvels five-issue comics Princess Leia (2015) which bridged the gap in the character arc from princess to
generalwhen the original trilogy had constructed a figure of female empowerment by denying those
characteristics. Lorna Jowett pursues the exploration of Disney Star Wars gendered politics through the
analysis of merchandising strategies for The Force Awakens in “Rey, Mary Sue, and Phasma Too.” The
film’s merchandising was met with negative responses from female fans as product lines initially obliterated
completely the character of Rey. These responses fueled the discussion on gender politics and inclusivity in
popular culture.
The chapters by Jones and Kent discuss the creative appropriation of content by fans. Bethan Joness
“Jafar Wars” examines the role played by fan productions in framing and anticipating the narrative
surrounding Disneys acquisition of the Star Wars franchise. Jones analyses fan fiction, art, and videos that
mix Disney and Star Wars texts and fan responses to these paratexts to show how they can play a role in fan
reception of the original texts. In “Fans Negotiating Disney’s (De)Stabilized Star Wars Canon,” Michelle
Kent discusses how fans negotiated Disneys rebranding of the Expanded Universe and announcements of
narrative departures in the up-coming trilogy. Analyzing responses from the two largest international Star
Wars costuming fan clubs, Kent shows that Disneys changes impacted real-world fan practice. Many fans
use Star Wars as a cultural object to enrich their lives through acts of civic engagement (such as supporting
childrens charities), and the decanonization of the Expanded Universe means disrupting such uses, thus
making fandom less meaningful.
Fan reactions and their incorporation by the studio are further analyzed in the next four chapters.
William Proctors “Fear of a #BlackStormtrooper” argues that the fan controversy surrounding the
appearance of John Boyega as a Stormtrooper in the original teaser for The Force Awakens was less about
race than it was about canonical authenticity. Proctor shows that the meanings of the controversy were partly
shaped by media responses to it and advocates a more complex reading of online fan activity than the
stereotyped binary between reactionary and progressive fans. Tom Phillips analyzes fans’ reaction videos to
trailers for The Force Awakens and compares them to actors Daisy Ridley and John Boyegas reaction
videos. He then argues that the film’s promotion used fannish discourses as an act of reassurance for
audiences and a perpetuation of the films culture of anticipation. Bridget Kies discusses the economy of
knowledge surrounding film releases and how fans actively manage and engineer their expectations and
access to information prior to release in Spoiler Culture, Marathon Screenings, and Affective Responses to
The Force Awakens. Using her own fan experience, Kies argues that such fan activities as accessing or
avoiding spoilers and behind-the-scene information, practicing screening marathons, and sharing energy
through group events meaningfully shape the screening experience, while such experience retains its inherent
power to surprise and affect fans in unexpected ways. Taking the opposite perspective, Lucy Bennett
discusses her own experience as a non-Star Wars viewer to explore the processes and meanings that can
occur when one remains unexposed to a cultural text. Being a non-viewer means being confronted with the
cultural shame of not being familiar with a canonical work. It also means having mediated knowledge of, and
expectations regarding, the unseen text charged through popular culture. Eventual viewing comes to confirm
or contradict expectations in complex ways, leading to an experience the author terms out-of-sync canonical
viewing (278).
Reviews, Caliban n°63
The closing chapters in part II adopt a broader look on the franchise from the perspectives of
narrative development and reception. Mark J. P. Wolfs “Beyond Vader: The Franchise Reawakens”
examines the four post-Lucas Star Wars feature films from The Force Awakens to Solo from a world-
building perspective as the franchise under Disney moves beyond the central character in the first six
episodes, Darth Vader. Wolf discusses the production choices regarding the new trilogy’s direction and the
ensuing mixed contribution of The Force Awakens to the Star Wars storyworld. Finally, William Proctors
“A New Hate? The War for Disney’s Star Wars addresses the online debate among fans and critics about
franchise fatigue and toxic fandom in the wake of the releases of The Last Jedi and Solo, and how the
franchise has lately been ensnared in the new culture wars. Proctor argues that the medias preeminent focus
on the most virulent elements of Star Wars fandom constructed a biased narrative that dramatized toxic
narratives at the expense of a fan majority.
The first edited collection focusing on Disneys purchase of Lucasfilm, Disneys Star Wars is a rich,
incisive, and valuable contribution to the study of transmedia franchises. The variety of perspectives,
approaches, and methodologies featured in the collection illustrates the multilayered consequences of the
purchase. One may regret the timing of the publication, with contributions that focus primarily on events
prior to and surrounding the release of The Force Awakens (2015), but this leaves room for future
publications that can offer an overarching perspective on the transmedia developments surrounding the
Disney Star Wars trilogy.
Mots clés
Disney, Star Wars, Lucasfilm, transmédialité, transmédia, production, promotion, réception, économie du
cinéma, études de fans
Keywords
Disney, Star Wars, Lucasfilm, transmedia, production, promotion, reception studies, fan studies, branding,
merchandising, franchising, media franchise
Index nominum
J. J. Abrams, Michael Arndt, Lucy Bennett, Paul Booth, Will Brooker, Douglas Brown, John Boyega, Peter
Cushing, Gareth Edwards, Matthew Freeman, Ross Garner, Lincoln Geraghty Jonathan Gray, Colin B.
Harvey, Dan Hassler-Forest, Matt Hills, Andrew Hoskins, Henry Jenkins, Derek Johnson, Bethan Jones,
Lorna Jowett, Michelle Kent, Bridget Kies, Dorling Kindersley, John Knoll, George Lucas, Richard
McCulloch, Ralph McQuarrie, Jason Mittell, Emma Pett, Tom Phillips, William Proctor, Daisy Ridley, Julie
Turnock, Rebecca Williams, Mark J. P. Wolf, Joshua Wucher, Timothy Zahn